Get backup power and energy gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Pool-specific collectors like the Doheny’s Grid prioritize surface area and flow rate over the thermal insulation found in domestic water heaters.
- The Heliatos SW-38 stands out as a hybrid solution, offering backup heating for cloudy days, a feature absent in pure solar pool kits.
- Evacuated tube collectors, such as the MISOL system, provide superior heat retention for domestic water but are overkill for pool applications.
- DIY kits like the SwimEasy reduce upfront costs but require more user skill to assemble and seal correctly to prevent leaks.
- Freeze protection is a critical differentiator for homeowners in colder climates, making hybrid or drain-back systems preferable to standard grid collectors.
| Doheny’s Solar Grid Pool Heating System |  | Best for Intex Pool Owners | Maximum Temperature Increase: Up to 5 degrees in 4 days | Package Dimensions: 57 x 35 x 8 inches | Item Weight: 43 pounds | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| FAFCO Solar Cub Above-Ground Pool Heating System, 2 ft × 20 ft, Add-On Kit |  | Best Expandable Add-On | Manufacturer: FAFCO | Panel Dimensions: 2 ft wide × 20 ft long | Compatibility: Above-ground swimming pools | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| SwimEasy DIY Solar Pool Heater Kit, Four 4 × 10 ft Panels, 1.5 in. I.D. Header |  | Best for DIY Enthusiasts | Manufacturer: Solar Pool Supply | Model: KIT-4-SPS15-10 | Panel Configuration: Four 4 × 10 ft panels | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Heliatos SW-38 Hybrid Solar Water Heater Kit, 2 Panels |  | Best for Domestic Hot Water | Manufacturer: Heliatos Solar | Model: SW-38 | Panel Count: 2 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| FAFCO Solar Cub Above-Ground Pool Solar Heater with Starter Kit, 2 ft. x 20 ft. |  | Best Complete Starter Package | Manufacturer: FAFCO | Dimensions: 2 ft. x 20 ft. | Mounting Options: Ground or rack | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| MISOL Solar Hot Water Collector with 10 Evacuated Heat Pipe Tubes |  | Best for DIY Enthusiasts | Tube Count: 10 | Tube Dimensions: 58 mm diameter × 500 mm length | Suggested Tank Capacity: 50 liters | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Heliatos SW-38 Hybrid Solar Water Heater Kit |  | Best for Cold Climates | Freeze Protection: Down to -30°F | PV Panel: 25W | Heat Exchanger: Stainless Steel, Alloy 316 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Doheny’s Solar Pool Heating System for Above-Ground Pools |  | Best for Above-Ground Pools | Collector Size: 5′ W x 20′ L | Panel Configuration: Two 2.5′ W x 20′ panels | Item Weight: 46 pounds | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| solar heating system | Manufacturer |
|---|---|
| Doheny’s Solar Grid Pool Heati | — |
| FAFCO Solar Cub Above-Ground P | FAFCO |
| SwimEasy DIY Solar Pool Heater | Solar Pool Supply |
| Heliatos SW-38 Hybrid Solar Wa | Heliatos Solar |
| FAFCO Solar Cub Above-Ground P | FAFCO |
| MISOL Solar Hot Water Collecto | MISOL |
| Heliatos SW-38 Hybrid Solar Wa | Heliatos Solar |
| Doheny’s Solar Pool Heating Sy | Doheny’s |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Doheny’s Solar Grid Pool Heating System
This system stands out because it includes adapters for Intex pools, removing a common barrier for above-ground users who otherwise struggle to connect third-party heaters. Unlike the FAFCO Solar Cub, which requires separate mounting solutions, the Doheny’s unit features angled legs and a clear cover designed to maximize heat collection immediately upon unboxing. However, this convenience comes with a significant caveat: it requires a filter pump that is not included, and in-ground setups demand a separate bypass kit. While the SwimEasy DIY Kit offers a more permanent, high-capacity solution for in-ground pools, the Doheny’s remains the most accessible entry point for existing Intex owners seeking to extend their swimming season without complex plumbing modifications.
Pros:- Includes specific adapters for Intex pool connections
- Angled legs and clear cover optimize solar heat collection
- Expandable design allows connecting multiple panels
- Lightweight at 43 pounds for easier positioning
Cons:- Filter pump is required but not included
- Bypass kit sold separately for in-ground pools or high-HP pumps
- Modest temperature increase of up to 5 degrees over 4 days
Best for: Owners of Intex above-ground pools who want a plug-and-play solution with included adapters.
Not ideal for: In-ground pool owners or those without a compatible filter pump, as the bypass kit and pump are sold separately.
- Maximum Temperature Increase:Up to 5 degrees in 4 days
- Package Dimensions:57 x 35 x 8 inches
- Item Weight:43 pounds
- Included Adapters:For Intex pools
- Pump Requirement:Required; not included
- Bypass Kit Requirement:Required for in-ground pools and pumps 1.5 HP or greater; sold separately
Our verdict“This is the most user-friendly option for Intex pool owners, provided you already have a compatible pump.”
FAFCO Solar Cub Above-Ground Pool Heating System, 2 ft × 20 ft, Add-On Kit
The FAFCO Solar Cub Add-On Kit is designed for users who already have a base system and want to scale up heating capacity without replacing their entire setup. Compared to the Doheny’s Solar Grid, this panel lacks integrated mounting legs or specific brand adapters, requiring you to supply your own rack or ground mounting solution. However, its slim 2-foot width makes it easier to integrate into existing arrays where space is limited. While the SwimEasy DIY Kit offers larger surface area per unit, the FAFCO Cub excels in modularity, allowing you to add heat incrementally as your budget or pool volume demands. It is a utilitarian choice for those who prioritize flexibility over out-of-the-box convenience.
Pros:- Modular design allows for easy system expansion
- Slim profile fits into constrained installation spaces
- Works seamlessly with existing pool pump circulation
Cons:- Mounting rack is not included
- Requires precise 10–30 degree south-facing tilt for performance
- Not a standalone solution for new installations
Best for: Users with existing FAFCO systems who need to expand heating capacity incrementally.
Not ideal for: First-time buyers who need a complete kit with mounting hardware and instructions for standalone installation.
- Manufacturer:FAFCO
- Panel Dimensions:2 ft wide × 20 ft long
- Compatibility:Above-ground swimming pools
- Mounting Options:Ground or rack (rack not included)
- Recommended Tilt:10–30 degrees toward the south
- Heating Method:Solar collector; water circulated by pool pump
Our verdict“This add-on is ideal for expanding an existing solar array, but it is too complex for standalone beginners.”
SwimEasy DIY Solar Pool Heater Kit, Four 4 × 10 ft Panels, 1.5 in. I.D. Header
This kit is engineered for those who want a permanent, high-capacity installation and are comfortable handling plumbing. The molded one-piece headers are a significant upgrade over the modular connections found in the Doheny’s Solar Grid, drastically reducing the risk of leaks over its 15–20 year service life. Unlike the FAFCO Solar Cub, which is designed for easier above-ground setups, the SwimEasy system requires integrating into an existing pump and filtration loop, demanding more technical skill. You receive extensive hardware and support, but you must supply the labor and tools. This is not a quick fix; it is a long-term infrastructure project that offers superior durability and heat retention compared to simpler grid-style panels.
Pros:- Molded one-piece headers reduce leak risks
- Long expected service life of 15–20 years
- Includes comprehensive mounting and plumbing hardware
- Expert installation support and manual provided
Cons:- Requires an existing pump and filtration system
- Installation and plumbing connections are required
- Large footprint requires significant installation space
Best for: Homeowners with existing pool plumbing who are comfortable with DIY installation and plumbing connections.
Not ideal for: Renters or those seeking a plug-and-play solution, as it requires permanent plumbing integration.
- Manufacturer:Solar Pool Supply
- Model:KIT-4-SPS15-10
- Panel Configuration:Four 4 × 10 ft panels
- Header Inner Diameter:1.5 in.
- Expected Service Life:15–20 years
- Compatibility:Connects to an existing pump and filtration system
- Included Components:Mounting hardware, panel connectors, tie-down strap, plumbing connections, installation manual, and expert installation support
Our verdict“This is the best choice for serious DIYers who want a durable, long-term heating solution for in-ground pools.”
Heliatos SW-38 Hybrid Solar Water Heater Kit, 2 Panels
Unlike the pool-specific heaters in this roundup, the Heliatos SW-38 targets domestic hot water, using a solar-powered pump to eliminate electrical grid dependency. While the SwimEasy DIY Kit heats large volumes of pool water slowly, the Heliatos system pre-heats household water, reducing the energy burden on your existing electric or gas heater. The panels thread together, avoiding the soldering required by many professional-grade systems, which simplifies installation for handy homeowners. However, it is not freeze protected, making it unsuitable for cold climates without additional antifreeze loops. It is a niche product for those looking to cut utility bills, rather than those seeking to heat a swimming pool.
Pros:- Solar-powered pump requires no grid electricity
- Connects to existing electric or gas water heaters
- Panels thread together without soldering
- Expandable with up to two additional panels
Cons:- Not freeze protected
- Not compatible with Marathon nonmetallic water heaters
- Requires separately supplied piping, fasteners, and insulation
Best for: Homeowners in mild climates looking to pre-heat domestic water and reduce electricity or gas bills.
Not ideal for: Pool owners or residents in areas prone to freezing temperatures, as the system lacks freeze protection.
- Manufacturer:Heliatos Solar
- Model:SW-38
- Panel Count:2
- Panel Dimensions:24 x 24 inches each
- Pump Power Source:10W photovoltaic panel
- Freeze Protection:None
- Installation Requirements:1/2-inch pipe, roof fasteners, pipe insulation, existing water heater, installation tools
Our verdict“This is a specialized system for domestic hot water savings, not a pool heater.”
FAFCO Solar Cub Above-Ground Pool Solar Heater with Starter Kit, 2 ft. x 20 ft.
The FAFCO Solar Cub Starter Kit improves upon the basic add-on model by including a dedicated installation kit, making it a more viable option for first-time buyers. While the Doheny’s Solar Grid offers specific Intex adapters, the FAFCO Cub focuses on universal above-ground compatibility with a ground or rack mounting strategy. It provides a similar heating principle to the SwimEasy DIY Kit but with a smaller footprint and less complex plumbing. The tradeoff is that you still need to orient the panel precisely toward the south for optimal results. This kit strikes a balance between the simplicity of a plug-and-play unit and the durability of a dedicated solar collector, making it a solid middle-ground choice for standard above-ground pools.
Pros:- Includes a complete installation kit
- Versatile ground or rack mounting options
- Standard 2 ft x 20 ft size fits most above-ground setups
Cons:- Requires specific south-facing tilt for best performance
- Limited review data available for long-term reliability assessment
- Does not include mounting rack
Best for: New above-ground pool owners who want a complete installation kit without needing brand-specific adapters.
Not ideal for: Users with non-standard pool fittings or those who cannot achieve a south-facing tilt of 10–30 degrees.
- Manufacturer:FAFCO
- Dimensions:2 ft. x 20 ft.
- Mounting Options:Ground or rack
- Recommended Tilt:10 to 30 degrees toward the south
- Compatibility:Above-ground swimming pools
- Included Items:Solar Cub heating system installation kit
Our verdict“This starter kit is the most balanced choice for new above-ground pool owners seeking a reliable solar heating system.”
MISOL Solar Hot Water Collector with 10 Evacuated Heat Pipe Tubes
This collector set is ideal for builders who want to create a custom domestic hot water system from scratch. Unlike the Heliatos SW-38 Hybrid Solar Water Heater Kit, which integrates directly with existing heaters, the MISOL unit requires you to supply your own storage tank and plumbing. It includes 10 evacuated heat pipe tubes, a manifold, and mounting hardware, offering high efficiency in a compact footprint. However, it is not suitable for swimming pools, limiting its application strictly to indoor water heating. The unassembled nature means you need technical skill to install it correctly, but the result is a highly efficient, low-maintenance system for a 50-liter tank.
Pros:- High-efficiency evacuated heat pipe tubes included
- Complete collector package with manifold and brackets
- Compact size suits small residential water heating needs
Cons:- Ships unassembled, requiring significant DIY effort
- Not compatible with swimming pool applications
Best for: DIY homeowners building a custom domestic hot water system with a compatible 50-liter storage tank.
Not ideal for: Pool owners or those seeking a plug-and-play solution, as it requires a separate tank and complex assembly.
- Tube Count:10
- Tube Dimensions:58 mm diameter × 500 mm length
- Suggested Tank Capacity:50 liters
- Manifold Material:Aluminum alloy
- Insulation Type:Rock wool
- Item Weight:50.6 pounds
- Manufacturer:MISOL
Our verdict“Choose this if you want a high-efficiency, custom-built domestic hot water collector and have the skills to assemble it.”
Heliatos SW-38 Hybrid Solar Water Heater Kit
Standout for its freeze protection down to -30°F, this kit is a robust choice for homeowners in harsh winters. It connects to your existing gas or electric water heater, using a stainless steel heat exchanger and food-grade propylene glycol. Compared to the Doheny’s Solar Pool Heating System, which focuses solely on pool water, the Heliatos system pre-heats domestic water, reducing energy costs year-round. The 25W PV panel powers the circulation pumps without needing a grid connection, adding reliability. While it requires separate piping and insulation, its hybrid nature ensures hot water availability even during cloudy periods.
Pros:- Operates in temperatures down to -30°F
- PV panel powers pumps independently of the grid
- Integrates with existing gas or electric water heaters
Cons:- Requires separate pipe, fasteners, and insulation
- Incompatible with Marathon non-metallic water heaters
Best for: Homeowners in cold regions looking to pre-heat domestic water using their existing gas or electric heater.
Not ideal for: Users with Marathon non-metallic water heaters, as the system is incompatible with those tanks.
- Freeze Protection:Down to -30°F
- PV Panel:25W
- Heat Exchanger:Stainless Steel, Alloy 316
- Panel Dimensions:24 × 24 inches each
- Heat Transfer Fluid:2 quarts food-grade propylene glycol
- Total Item Weight:66 lbs
- Manufacturer:Heliatos Solar
Our verdict“This is the smartest choice for cold-climate homes wanting to lower water heating bills without grid-dependent pumps.”
Doheny’s Solar Pool Heating System for Above-Ground Pools
Designed specifically for above-ground pools, this 5′ x 20′ collector kit delivers 80,000 BTU of solar heating power. It is a direct competitor to the SwimEasy DIY Solar Pool Heater Kit, but its two-panel configuration offers a simpler installation path for smaller pools. The system uses sunlight to warm circulating water, extending the swimming season without electricity. However, it does not include PVC or flex pipes, meaning you must purchase plumbing components separately. While mounting hardware is provided, you still need a roof or rack mounting kit, making it a semi-DIY project that requires careful planning for plumbing and support.
Pros:- 80,000 BTU capacity for efficient pool warming
- Includes stainless steel mounting brackets and screws
- Panels can be connected in series for expansion
Cons:- PVC or flex pipes are not included
- Requires a separate roof or rack mounting kit
Best for: Owners of above-ground pools seeking to extend the swimming season with a high-BTU solar collector.
Not ideal for: Those wanting a complete plug-and-play kit, as pipes and mounting racks are sold separately.
- Collector Size:5′ W x 20′ L
- Panel Configuration:Two 2.5′ W x 20′ panels
- Item Weight:46 pounds
- Included Hardware:Straps, brackets, screws
- Manufacturer:Doheny’s
Our verdict“Perfect for above-ground pool owners who are ready to handle their own plumbing and mounting needs.”
How We Picked
I evaluated these systems based on three primary criteria: thermal efficiency, installation complexity, and durability under varying weather conditions. For pool systems, I focused on collector surface area relative to flow rate, ensuring the unit could actually raise water temperature without excessive pump load. For domestic water heaters, I prioritized insulation quality and freeze protection mechanisms, as these factors determine year-round viability.
I also compared customer-reported longevity and maintenance requirements. Systems requiring frequent seal replacements or prone to clogging were ranked lower. The ranking reflects a balance between performance and practicality, favoring options that offer a clear return on investment through reduced energy bills and minimal upkeep.
| solar heating system | Manufacturer |
|---|---|
| Doheny’s Solar Grid Pool Heati | — |
| FAFCO Solar Cub Above-Ground P | FAFCO |
| SwimEasy DIY Solar Pool Heater | Solar Pool Supply |
| Heliatos SW-38 Hybrid Solar Wa | Heliatos Solar |
| FAFCO Solar Cub Above-Ground P | FAFCO |
| MISOL Solar Hot Water Collecto | MISOL |
| Heliatos SW-38 Hybrid Solar Wa | Heliatos Solar |
| Doheny’s Solar Pool Heating Sy | Doheny’s |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Solar Heating Systems
Selecting a solar heating system requires matching the technology to your specific application and climate. Here are the key factors to weigh before making a purchase.Pool vs. Domestic Water Applications
These two categories use fundamentally different technologies. Pool heaters typically use unglazed plastic or rubber collectors that are exposed directly to the sun, relying on high volume and low temperature rise. Domestic water heaters use glazed flat plates or evacuated tubes to reach higher temperatures, often up to 150°F or more. Do not use a pool heater for domestic water as it will not reach sufficient temperatures for bathing or cleaning. Conversely, a domestic heater is too expensive and complex for a pool, offering diminishing returns on heat gain.
Climate and Freeze Protection
Your geographic location dictates the necessary features. In warm, sunny climates, simple grid collectors work year-round. However, if you live in an area with freezing winters, you need a system with freeze protection. This might mean a drain-back system that empties the panels when the sun goes down, or a heat-trace cable system. The 2-Panel Freeze-Protected Hybrid Solar Water Heater Kit addresses this directly, whereas standard pool grids will crack if left filled with water in freezing temperatures.
Installation Complexity and DIY Feasibility
Some systems are designed for professional installation, involving complex plumbing, roof penetrations, or structural reinforcements. Others, like the SwimEasy DIY Kit, are modular and designed for homeowner assembly. Assess your plumbing skills honestly. A poorly installed domestic system can cause water damage. For pool kits, the challenge is usually connecting to the existing pump and filter system without introducing air leaks, which can damage the pump. Consider hiring a professional if the kit requires roof mounting or high-pressure connections.
Sizing and Roof Space Requirements
Solar heating is a space-intensive technology. A general rule of thumb for pools is that the collector area should be 75% to 100% of the pool’s surface area. For domestic water, a typical family of four needs 20 to 40 square feet of collector area. Measure your available roof or ground space before buying. Undersizing the system is a common mistake that leads to disappointment, as the system will only heat water partially or for short periods.
Pump and Controller Compatibility
Most solar systems require a dedicated pump or rely on your existing pool pump. Domestic systems often need a differential controller that turns the pump on when the collector is hotter than the tank. Check if your existing pool pump has enough head pressure to push water through the collector. If not, you may need to add a booster pump, which increases energy costs and complexity. Verify compatibility with your current setup to avoid hidden costs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a solar pool heater to heat my shower water?
No, you should not attempt to use a solar pool heater for domestic water. Pool heaters are designed for low-temperature, high-volume applications and typically only raise water temperature by a few degrees above ambient. Domestic water heating requires temperatures between 120°F and 140°F to be effective and sanitary. A pool collector lacks the insulation and glazing needed to reach these temperatures, meaning you would get lukewarm water at best and risk bacterial growth due to insufficient heating.
How much does a solar heating system increase my electricity bill?
The system itself does not generate electricity, but it does require pumps and controllers to operate. For a pool system, the pump runs during daylight hours, adding roughly 1 to 3 cents per hour to your electric bill depending on your local rates and pump size. Domestic systems use smaller circulation pumps that consume very little power, often less than 50 watts. The net savings on gas or electric water heating usually far outweigh this small operational cost, often paying for themselves in 3 to 7 years.
Do I need a backup heater for my solar water system?
Most domestic solar water heating systems come with a backup electric or gas element integrated into the storage tank. This is necessary because solar energy is intermittent; cloudy days or high demand can deplete the solar-heated water. Without a backup, you would have no hot water during these times. The Heliatos SW-38 is a good example of a hybrid system that integrates this backup seamlessly. Always check if the kit includes the backup element or if it must be purchased separately.
How long do solar heating panels last?
With proper maintenance, solar thermal collectors can last 20 to 30 years. Glazed flat-plate and evacuated tube collectors are durable but vulnerable to hail damage or seal degradation over time. Unglazed pool collectors, made of rubber or plastic, are more susceptible to UV degradation and may need replacement every 5 to 10 years. Regular cleaning and checking for leaks in the plumbing connections will extend the lifespan of any system. Investing in higher-quality materials, like copper or stainless steel, often yields better longevity than cheaper aluminum or plastic alternatives.
Can I install a solar heating system on a flat roof?
Yes, but you must account for the angle of incidence. Solar panels perform best when tilted toward the equator at an angle roughly equal to your latitude. On a flat roof, you will need mounting racks or ballasted stands to tilt the panels. This increases the wind profile of the installation, so you must ensure the roof structure can handle the additional weight and wind load. Some systems, like the Doheny’s Grid, can be laid flat on the ground or roof, accepting a slight efficiency loss for easier installation and lower structural requirements.
Conclusion
Choosing the best solar heating system comes down to matching the right technology to your specific needs. For pool owners, the Doheny’s Solar Grid Pool Heating System is the best overall choice due to its proven durability and efficiency. If you are on a tighter budget and comfortable with assembly, the SwimEasy DIY Solar Pool Heater Kit offers the best value. For homeowners looking for a complete domestic water solution, the Heliatos SW-38 Hybrid Solar Water Heater Kit is the premium pick, offering reliability and backup heating. In colder climates, prioritize the 2-Panel Freeze-Protected Hybrid to avoid winter damage. Always verify your roof space and pump compatibility before purchasing to ensure a smooth installation.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
